A Delaware Statutory Trust, or DST, can be an attractive solution for commercial real estate investors completing a 1031 exchange. It offers investors the ability to defer capital gains taxes, access institutional-quality real estate, diversify across properties and potentially eliminate the day-to-day responsibilities of property ownership.
However, one factor is often overlooked: Exchanging directly owned real estate for a DST investment involves a significant trade-off.
The investor gives up control, flexibility and direct ownership in exchange for a passive investment with a very different set of risks.
DSTs can play an important role in a 1031 exchange strategy, but they are not appropriate for every investor. Before committing exchange proceeds, investors should understand the potential financial, operational, tax and liquidity consequences.
Here are some of the most important issues to examine before moving forward.
1. You Give Up Control of the Real Estate
Perhaps the greatest disadvantage of a DST is the loss of control.
When investors directly own an apartment building, retail center, industrial property or another commercial asset, they can decide when to sell, refinance, renovate, change property management, negotiate leases or pursue a different investment strategy in response to market conditions.
With a DST, investors generally have no meaningful authority over these decisions. The sponsor and trustee control the investment, including property management, leasing, capital expenditures and the eventual disposition of the property.
In some cases, the fees collected for managing the DST may also reduce a sponsor’s incentive to sell early when market conditions change.
The potential consequence: If the property begins to underperform, the investor cannot simply replace the property manager, sell the asset, refinance the debt or implement a new business plan. Investors remain dependent on the sponsor’s decisions, even when those decisions may not align with their individual financial objectives.
2. Your Investment May Be Illiquid for Years
DST investments are generally structured as long-term investments, often with projected holding periods of five to ten years. There is also typically no established secondary market for DST interests.
Unlike directly owned real estate, which an investor can generally list for sale when market conditions are favorable, DST interests do not trade on an established public market.
Some sponsors may facilitate secondary-market transactions, but there is no guarantee that a buyer will be available or that an investor will recover the original investment. Secondary-market buyers may also seek significant discounts when an investor needs to sell early.
The potential consequence: An investor who needs access to capital because of an unexpected expense, retirement needs, another investment opportunity, health concerns or changing financial circumstances may be unable to obtain it.
This is especially important for investors who are accustomed to directly owning real estate and having the ability to liquidate an asset when they choose.
3. The Seven Deadly Sins: Restrictions on What a DST Can Do
One of the lesser-understood aspects of DST ownership involves the IRS restrictions commonly referred to as the “Seven Deadly Sins.”
Under IRS Revenue Ruling 2004-86, certain DST structures must operate under specific restrictions to maintain their tax classification and qualify as replacement property in a 1031 exchange.
Generally, these restrictions limit the trustee’s ability to:
Renegotiate existing leases or enter into new leases
Renegotiate or refinance existing debt
Obtain additional financing
Make significant capital improvements beyond limited exceptions
Invest cash reserves to generate additional investment returns
Acquire additional properties or dispose of existing property outside permitted circumstances
Accept additional capital contributions from investors
These restrictions are important because they can limit the sponsor’s ability to respond to changing market conditions and may prevent the asset from reaching its full return potential.
The potential consequence: Imagine that a DST owns an office building experiencing significant tenant departures. The sponsor may have limited flexibility to restructure the investment, obtain additional capital or make substantial improvements to reposition the property.
What might otherwise be a manageable real estate challenge could become a much larger financial problem.
These restrictions represent part of the trade-off for receiving the desired 1031 exchange tax treatment.
4. Leverage Can Create Additional Financial Risk
Many DST investments use financing to acquire properties. Although leverage can improve potential returns, it can also increase risk.
Investors should understand:
The amount of debt associated with the property
The loan’s maturity date
The interest-rate structure
Amortization requirements
Whether the loan carries a fixed or floating interest rate
Refinancing is a particularly important concern in a market experiencing higher interest rates and more conservative lender underwriting.
If the property is not sold before its loan matures, the sponsor may have difficulty refinancing, especially if interest rates have increased, property values have declined or operating income has weakened.
The potential consequence: A property generating adequate cash flow today could experience financial distress when its loan matures. If refinancing is unavailable or offered on unfavorable terms, the property could be forced into a sale at an undesirable time, potentially resulting in a substantial loss of investor capital.
Investors should not assume that a property with positive cash flow today will necessarily remain financially viable throughout the entire investment period.
5. Fees Can Significantly Reduce Your Actual Return
DST offerings can involve multiple layers of fees and expenses, including:
Acquisition and organizational fees
Sponsor and structuring fees
Asset management fees
Property management fees
Financing and loan-origination expenses
Disposition fees when the property is sold
Some fees are paid upfront and may be incorporated into the offering price rather than appearing as a separate expense to the investor.
This is especially important when investors compare projected DST returns with the income they previously generated from directly owned real estate.
The potential consequence: An investor may believe they are purchasing an interest in a property at a certain valuation when the actual value of the underlying real estate is lower after accounting for offering expenses and sponsor compensation.
Investors should carefully examine the private placement memorandum, understand the complete fee structure and determine how much of their investment is actually being applied toward the acquisition of real estate.
6. Concentration Risk and Dependence on the Sponsor
Not all DSTs provide the same level of diversification.
Some DSTs own a single apartment complex, industrial building or retail property, while others hold multiple assets. Even when a DST owns several properties, those assets may be concentrated in one geographic market or property sector.
The investor is also relying heavily on the sponsor’s experience, financial strength, integrity and ability to manage the investment.
The potential consequence: Poor sponsor decisions, unexpected vacancies, tenant defaults, declining market conditions or inadequate property reserves could negatively affect distributions and ultimately reduce the value of the investment.
Investors should investigate the sponsor’s track record, including:
Previous offerings
Realized investment returns
Properties that have underperformed
Whether projected returns have historically been achieved
7. Your Exit Strategy May Create Another Tax Problem
An important consideration investors sometimes overlook is what happens when the DST eventually sells its property.
Although the original exchange may successfully defer capital gains taxes, the tax liability does not disappear.
When the DST sells its underlying real estate, investors may receive proceeds that create a taxable event unless another qualifying tax strategy is implemented.
Depending on the structure of the offering and the investor’s circumstances, the investor may not be able to complete another 1031 exchange after the DST sells the property. Other exchange opportunities or tax strategies may still be available, but investors should never assume that another deferral will happen automatically.
There may also be limitations involving the timing, structure and availability of suitable replacement investments.
The potential consequence: An investor who originally completed a 1031 exchange to defer taxes may eventually face a significant tax liability when the DST investment terminates.
Investors should discuss the anticipated disposition strategy with their tax advisor before purchasing the DST rather than waiting until the property is sold.
8. You Still Have to Meet the 1031 Exchange Requirements
Purchasing an interest in a DST does not eliminate the traditional requirements of a 1031 exchange.
Generally, replacement property must be identified within 45 days of selling the relinquished property and acquired within 180 days—or by the applicable tax-return due date, including extensions, if that date comes first.
Investors seeking full tax deferral generally must also reinvest all net exchange proceeds and replace the debt associated with the relinquished property through qualifying replacement-property debt or an additional cash investment.
The debt component deserves particular attention when investing in a DST because the investor is purchasing a fractional beneficial interest in a trust that may already have financing in place.
The potential consequence: An improperly structured exchange, insufficient replacement value or failure to satisfy the applicable debt and equity requirements could result in taxable boot and an unexpected tax bill.
The Bottom Line: Tax Deferral Should Not Drive the Entire Investment Decision
DSTs can be useful investment vehicles, particularly for investors seeking passive ownership, diversification and an opportunity to defer capital gains taxes without the responsibilities of directly managing commercial real estate.
However, the potential tax advantages should never overshadow the underlying investment fundamentals.
Before committing exchange proceeds, investors should carefully evaluate:
The underlying property or properties
The sponsor
The financing
The complete fee structure
Projected cash flow
The anticipated holding period
The disposition strategy
Potential downside scenarios
Perhaps the most important question to ask is:
If this investment were not eligible for a 1031 exchange, would I still want to invest my money in it?
If the answer is no, it may be worth reconsidering the investment.
A successful 1031 exchange is not simply about avoiding taxes today. It is about making a sound long-term investment decision that preserves capital, generates an acceptable return and supports the investor’s overall financial objectives.
If you would like to explore DSTs or other assets that may help complete your 1031 exchange, please contact us at info@cbicommercial.com.
Disclaimer: This article is for educational purposes only and does not constitute tax, legal or investment advice. DST offerings involve securities and real estate investment risks, including the potential loss of principal. Investors should consult qualified tax, legal and financial professionals before investing.